alextheboss

@Aristeaus: I'll keep this short since we might have a CAVHow does some jedi losing to Sidious or Anakin even remotely imply that they didn't gain strength during the clone wars? You are getting off t...

@Aristeaus: Cool. So you think he is trash too then.Huh? If you think Maul could possibly be below average master level you are truly lost.That is not how the word Prodigy is used.You can't be a prodi...

@lord_tenebrous: excellent post

@Aristeaus: Grasping at straws now.Not really. There can be a few elite jedi that surpassed Palpatine's expectations, but it's clear in general Palpatine though Maul was above jedi level. Maul clearly...

@joesmithy226 said: @alextheboss said: @joesmithy226: Grievous is physically stronger than all force users in the movies. There is no proof Kenobi ever surpassed Maul in physical strength.who was the ...

@joesmithy226: Grievous is physically stronger than all force users in the movies. There is no proof Kenobi ever surpassed Maul in physical strength.

@Aristeaus: If you argue that Palpatine didn't know how strong Yoda or Mace was; that same argument can apply to any Jedi.That's only one possibility. Another I gave is Palpatine new Yoda wouldn't lea...

@greysentinel365 : is this all from the novel?

@greysentinel365: isn't legends Maul also injured during the Naboo fight? Maul fought Qui-gon on an open desert on Tatooine and Qui-gon still barely survived, what's the explanation behind that?

@macattack1 said:I’d go with the Jedi duo in a good fight. Qui Gon alone is enough to give Maul a high diff fight, so with Sharad (a highly esteemed Jedi master) by his side I think they can win. I’m...

Vader should win this. Adam's greatest advantage is his movement speed but Vader should be able to lock him down with the force. The force can also stop incoming projectiles.

@Aristeaus: Him beating Maul; and QG's death and last wish nudged them. Him beating Maul didn't "prove" anything; the council had no idea how strong or skillful a Sith is as none of them had seen one ...

@Aristeaus:He was the first person to beat a Sith in 1000 years so yeah that probably effected how they thought about him. That doesn't mean he was ready before hand.Him beating Maul proved he was rea...

@Aristeaus: He didn't say it exactly like that but the council decides when someone is ready; and since Obi-Wan is 25 and still a Padawan, they did not think he was ready.We don't know the inner mecha...